Center for Judicial Excellence

Justice. Accountability. Integrity.

  • About Us
    • Board of Directors
    • CJE Staff
  • Donate
  • Contact CJE
  • Email
  • Facebook
  • Instagram
  • Twitter
  • YouTube
  • Initiatives
    • Advocacy
      • Media Advocacy
      • Policy & Legislation
      • Prior Legislative Victories
    • Educating Oversight Agencies
    • U.S. Divorce Child Murder Data
    • Marin Court Misconduct
  • Multimedia
    • Kids of Divorce Speak Out
    • CJE in the News
      • PRINT
      • TV & RADIO
      • Press Releases
    • The Director’s Corner
    • Multimedia Projects
      • Film
      • Photo Exhibit
      • Slideshow
    • Photo Gallery
  • Events
    • Upcoming Events
    • Previous Forums & Events
    • 10 Year Anniversary Campaign
  • Take Action!
    • Join CJE
  • Resources
    • Family Court Crisis Background
    • Domestic Violence & Child Abuse Resources
    • Pro Bono Services, Self-Help Centers & Court Information
  • Membership
  • News
  • Blog
You are here: Home / Blog / Mercurio Dissertation: The California Family Court System

Mercurio Dissertation: The California Family Court System

November 11, 2016

THE CALIFORNIA FAMILY COURT SYSTEM: EXPERIENCES OF PROTECTIVE MOTHERS OF ABUSED CHILDREN

Michelle Kathleen Mercurio
Saybrook University

There is a national epidemic of children being physically, sexually, emotionally, and verbally abused and/or neglected by their fathers as a result of custody and visitation orders by the family court system (Rosin, 2014). In addition, the family court system mistreats mothers and children while violating both national and international human rights’ laws. This mixed method study explores the experiences of mothers (herein referred to as “protective mothers”) in California who attempt to protect their children while going through the custody and visitation process.

The study included 24 protective mothers who were recruited from the websites of the Center for Judicial Excellence, the California Protective Parents Association, and Facebook. The protective mothers took a 64-item anonymous online survey that collected both quantitative and narrative data, and were offered an optional follow-up interview via telephone. The survey addressed seven categories, including: “respondent demographics,” “protection of child’s best interests,” “protection of child’s safety,” “equitable treatment of mothers,” “protection of mothers’ safety,” “effectiveness of the California family court system,” and the “adherence with national and international human rights legislation.”

The quantitative data were tabulated and the survey and interview responses were examined to identify common themes, consistent with the content analysis procedure outlined by Saldana (2011). The data showed that the protective mothers and their children are being abused and had negative experiences in the California family court system, which included mistreatment by the Judges, court officers, mediators, law enforcement, and the California Protective Services. A discrepancy was also found between national and international human rights’ laws and the treatment of the protective mothers and their children. The protective mothers took an active role in the research.

This study takes a broad approach to the issue, including both the subjective experiences of the participants and a comparison of those experiences to national and international human rights’ law. Suggestions for further research are included.

Read the full dissertation HERE. 

 

Share this:

  • Tweet
  • More
  • Share on Tumblr
  • Pocket
  • Print

Filed Under: Blog

Family Law Documentary Trailer

Recent News

Press Release: Congress Works to Ensure Children Are Protected in Custody Disputes

September 26, 2018

H. CON. RES. 72 Pushes State Courts to Consider … [Read More...]

The Daily Beast: The Chaotic Life and Death of Former Playboy Playmate Stephanie Adams

May 19, 2018

Rest in peace, 7-year-old Vincent. CJE's child … [Read More...]

The Problem with Family Court – ABC News Investigation

May 10, 2018

“Family court handles divorces, the division of … [Read More...]

Marin Voice: New film exposes crisis in U.S. family courts

April 5, 2018

April is Child Abuse Awareness Month. For those of … [Read More...]

More news

News Archive

Contact Us

P.O. Box 150793
San Rafael, California 94915
Phone: 415-444-6556
Email:
info@centerforjudicialexcellence.org

Find Us on Facebook

Follow CJE on Twitter

My Tweets

Email List Signup

CJE DOES NOT GIVE LEGAL ADVICE. If you have a legal problem, seek professional legal counsel. We want to hear your story, however, please be advised, if you choose to share information with us, we can not guarantee your privacy.

 

Copyright © 2019 Center for Judicial Excellence. All Rights Reserved.

Log in